View Single Post
Old 18 Aug 2012, 21:18   #7
Mercutio
Guru
 
Mercutio
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 1,333
Originally Posted by Twinsen:
Originally Posted by Mercutio:
twisen, acuma, daca tot i-ai facut reclama, deci se stie ca tu ai ales acest film, te-as intreba de ce l-ai ales? crezi ca se potriveste aici? cui i se adreseaza? adolescentilor? poate, dar e atat de slab. ne jigneste in demnitatea noastra de cinefili, ca sa zic asa, referindu-ma la cei care comenteaza aici.
Eu as zice ca nu jigneste pe cei care posteaza aici, ba chiar dimpotriva, daca citim de exemplu parerea lui Liviu: http://www.cinemagia.ro/forum/showth...#p ost1524315.

Daca ne uitam la nota de 7.9 pe imbd si la comentarii descoperim ca nu jigneste defel nici pe altii.

Si daca, stiind ca iti plac criticii de renume, ne uitam la ce spun domnii de la Sight & Sound iata ce gasim: "Among the great strengths of this remarkable film is the way such weighty issues are dramatised through the machinations of the story. Its seriousness, and indeed its utter sincerity, lurk behind layers of seemingly superficial naughtiness (...) In celluloid terms, the film's combination of below-the-belt humour, frolicsome farce and unexpected emotional potency perhaps recalls prime Almodóvar, while even Rivette might envy the long-form control of the shifting plates of its narrative. That said, perhaps the most appropriate epithet lies elsewhere, for in its proudly confident layering of the high-falutin' and the low-slung, its insistence that the portals of vulgarity offer the truest perspective on the human condition, it can really only be called Shakespearean. It's a description that precious few films of the past decade might warrant, but one that Love Exposure deserves. Triumphantly." (http://old.bfi.org.uk/sightandsound/review/5175)

exagereaza nenea asta. ce sa-ti povestesc, shakespearean, hai sa fim seriosi. eu nu iau de bun tot ce se scrie intr-o revista. in plus in cadrul unei reviste exista mereu pareri diferite. asta e parerea unuia dintre cei care scriu acolo.
de altfel, e interesant cum esti tu de acord acuma cu S&S, cand pe threadul celalalt zici ca topurile lor n-au nici o valoare.

pune si o nota te rog!
Mercutio is offline   Reply With Quote sendpm.gif