|
SONDAJ: Top Filme 2012
REGULAMENT
Sondajul are, ca in fiecare an, 2 capitole: - Top 10 Released - filme care au avut premiera in Romania in 2012. Lista filmelor eligibile: http://www.cinemagia.ro/boxoffice/premiere/?year=2012 Pot fi incluse in acest top si alte filme care nu sunt in lista de mai sus dar despre care aveti informatii sigure ca au rulat cel putin o saptamana intreaga la cinema in Romania (in afara festivalurilor). Data limita pentru postarea topului personal la aceasta categorie este 31 Ianuarie 2013. - Top 10 Unreleased - filme care au avut premiera in 2012 (in cel putin o tara) dar nu s-au lansat in Romania. Data limita pentru postarea topului personal la aceasta categorie este 28 Februarie 2013 (in luna februarie circula prin lume multe DVD-uri "for awards consideration" cu filme eligibile pentru acest top). Pe masura ce vedeti noi filme, va puteti updata topurile postate initial, pana la deadline-ul mentionat. Nu e nevoie sa editati si in postarea initiala. Ultima varianta de topuri a fiecaruia va fi cea luata in considerare. Daca nu considerati ca ati vazut 10 filme bune, puteti pune si mai putine in top (minim 5). Calitate nu cantitate ! Pentru clasamentul final se va puncta cu 10p filmul de pe locul 1, 9p - locul 2 .... 1p - locul 10 |
Top 10 Released
1. Oslo, 31. august ( Joachim Trier) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 4. Argo (Ben Affleck) 5. Haywire (Steven Soderbergh) 6. The Descendants (Alexander Payne) Mai am de vazut: Holy Motors, După dealuri, Life of Pi, Looper, Skyfall, The Hobbit (Nu ca le-as fi vazut pe toate cele nementionate dar peste multe am sarit pur si simplu) Top 10 Unreleased 1. Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson) Din segmentul asta n-am vazut decat vreo 2 filme. Lista ramasa e foarte lunga si n-are rost s-o mai desfasor. |
Top 10 Released *
1). Toata Lumea Din Familia Noastra (Jude) 2). Holy Motors (Carax) 3). Killer Joe (Friedkin) 4). Despre Oameni Si Melci (Giurgiu) 5). Dredd (Travis) Top 10 Unreleased 1). Just The Wind (Fliegauf) 2). Amour (Haneke) 3). Living (Sigarev) 4). Compliance (Zobel) 5). Beasts of The Southern Wild (Zeitlin) 6). La Noche De Enfrente (Ruiz) 7). Quitting Smoking By Smoking (Pacinotti) 8). Moonrise Kingdom (Anderson) 9). Paradise: Love (Seidl) 10). Apres Mai (Assayas) * : Singurele pe care le-am vazut si care merita un loc. Mai sunt cateva OK, dar nu sunt chiar atat de bune. |
1. Holy Motors (Carax)
2. Oslo, August 31st (J. Trier) 3. We Need to Talk About Kevin (Lynne Ramsay) 4. După dealuri (Mungiu) 5. Argo (Ben Afleck) 6. Le gamin au vélo ( Dardennes) 7. Sin retorno (Miguel Cohan) 8. Polisse (Maïwenn) 9. La vida de los peces (Matias Bize) 10. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) Mi-au mai placut: Hesher, Killer Joe, Le Havre De vazut si: En kongelig affære, End of watch |
Si un provizoriu Top 10 Unreleased
1. Moonrise Kingdom, Wes Anderson 2. Compliance , Craig Zobel 3. Paradies: Liebe, Ulrich Seidl 4. Beasts of the Southern Wild, Benh Zeitlin 5. Laurence Anyways, Xavier Dolan 6. Arbitrage, Nicholas Jarecki 7. Margaret, Kenneth Lonergan 8. De rouille et d'os, Jacques Audiard Foarte dificil de facut departajarea intre primele pozitii, niciunul nu se detaseaza clar de pluton. E timp, insa, pan la sfarsitul anului, zilele astea sper sa vad si Amour, Pieta si Barbara. Or mai fi cateva, da-mi scapa acu. |
Top 10 Released:
1. Cloud Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 4. Argo (Ben Affleck) 5. War Horse (Steven Spielberg) 6. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 7. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 8. John Carter (Andrew Stanton) 9. Looper (Rian Johnson) |
Top 10 Released
1. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (Peter Jackson) 2. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 3. Could Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 4. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 5. The Avengers (Joss Whedon) 6. Argo (Ben Affleck) 7. Men in Black 3 (Barry Sonnenfeld) 8. Looper (Rian Johnson) 9. Ted (Seth MacFarlane) 10. Prometheus (Ridley Scott) |
O sa dau un top 10 overall (released & unreleased), dupa care il sparg in doua cum mi s-a cerut:
Top 10 overall 1. Beasts of the Southern Wild 2. Oslo, August 31st 3. La vida de los peces 4. Tabu 5. Dupa dealuri 6. In another country 7. Moonrise kingdom 8. Like someone in love 9. Holy motors 10. Toata lumea din familia noastra Top Released 1. Oslo, August 31st 2. La vida de los peces 3. Dupa dealuri 4. Holy motors 5. Toata lumea din familia noastra 6. The dark knight rises Top Unreleased 1. Beasts of the Southern Wild 2. Tabu 3. In another country 4. Moonrise kingdom 5. Like someone in love Mai am de vazut pana in februarie, mai adaug atunci. Later Edit: n-am vazut initial ca "La vida de los peces" e eligibil pt anul asta, am modificat :) |
Originally Posted by Mr.J:
Well done! , Mr. J.. cu două excepții de : 1. Anna Karenina și fără Mac..Fa.t |
Top 10 Released
1. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 2. Could Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 3. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy 4. The Descendants 5. The Artist 6. Looper (Rian Johnson) 7. The Avengers (Joss Whedon) 8. The Hunger Games 9. Argo 10. Skyfall |
Released:
1. Oslo, August 31st 2. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 3. We Need to Talk About Kevin 4. Dupa Dealuri 5. Holy Motors 6. Le Havre 7. Looper Unreleased: 1. Amour 2. In the fog 3. Moonrise kingdom 4. Like someone in love 5. Killing them softly 6. The cabin in the woods 7. In another country 8. Pieta 9. Beasts of the southern wild |
Seriously, trebuie sa schimbam putin regulile la unreleased. Cum pana mea sa sarim peste Shame?
|
pana mea, Shame a fost votat la Unreleased anul trecut.
buticut il avea chiar pe primul loc. |
buticut e singura care l-a vazut si asta pt ca n-a mai putut astepta si a vazut o varianta cam. Eu sunt aproape sigur ca daca s-ar fi putut vota anul trecut prindea macar top 3. Si anul asta la fel.
|
Of si buti asta. Cum seamana ea discordie pe forum pt ca a mancat-o si n-a putut astepta un dvdrip. :))
Bun. Ideea e in felul urmator: regula actuala de la unreleased e pusa acolo ca sa vorbim toti aceeasi limba, sa avem aceeasi baza de selectie si sa nu adunam la sfarsit mere cu pere. Daca ar fi venit cineva cu una mai buna as fi acceptat-o. Nu ma deranjeaza cu nimic sa o schimbam dar cu ce ? E mai bine sa lasam ceva larg de genul "filme care s-au lansat in 2012" si sa inteleaga fiecare ce vrea din asta ? Dpmdv e ok si asa. Dar mi-e ca deschidem cutia Pandorei si o sa vina unii cu filme de prin 2010 sau mai vechi, pe care ei le-au vazut abia in 2012. Repet: regula e perfectibila si o putem schimba, dar veniti cu ceva concret, supunem la vot si daca trece motiunea ... il demitem pe Basescu. |
Top 10 Released:
1. Cloud Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. Life of Pi (Ang Lee) 4. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 5. Argo (Ben Affleck) 6. War Horse (Steven Spielberg) 7. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 8. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 9. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (Peter Jackson) 10. John Carter (Andrew Stanton) |
Un Top 5, deocamdata:
1. Holy Motors (Leos Carax) 2. Oslo, 31. august ( Joachim Trier) 3. După dealuri (Cristian Mungiu) 4. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 5. Cosmopolis (David Cronenberg) |
marcus, unde ai văzut living al lui sigarev?
se găsește sau ceva festival? |
Top 10 Released
1. După dealuri (Cristian Mungiu)
2. Oslo, August 31st (Joachim Trier) 3. Intouchables (Olivier Nakache, Eric Toledano) 4. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 5. The Dark Knight Rises (Cristopher Nolan) 6. Hodejegerne (Morten Tyldum) 7. Prometheus (Ridley Scott) 8. The Descendants (Alexander Payne) 9. Despre oameni și melci (Tudor Giurgiu) 10. Și caii sunt verzi pe pereți (Dan Chișu) ... și ar mai fi :D 11. Dark shadows (Tim Burton) 12. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 13. The Avengers (Joss Whedon) ... nu m-am putut abține :D |
Originally Posted by Malombra:
KG. |
update Released
1. Oslo, August 31st ( Joachim Trier) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. Dupa Dealuri (Cristian Mungiu) 4. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 5. Holy Motors (Leos Carax) 6. Argo (Ben Affleck) 7. Haywire (Steven Soderbergh) 8. The Descendants (Alexander Payne) |
Top 10 Released
1. Holy Motors 2. Habemus papam 3. Oslo, 31. august 4. L'apollonide 5. Le gamin au velo 6. End of Watch 7. J. Edgar 8. Dupa dealuri 9. Sin retorno 10. The Artist |
Top 10 lansate:
1. The descendants 2. End of watch 3. Celeste and Jesse forever 4. We need to talk about Kevin 5. Toată lumea din familia noastră 6. Diaz 7. Holy Motors 8. Argo 9. My week with Marylin 10. Skyfall |
My Top 10 Released
1. Dupa Dealuri 2. We need to talk about Kevin 3. Cloud Atlas 4. End of Watch 5. The Artist 6. Argo 7. Oslo, 31 august 8. La source des femmes 9. Hesher 10. The Angel's Share |
Update:
Top 10 Released: 1. Cloud Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. Life of Pi (Ang Lee) 4. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 5. Lawless (John Hillcoat) 6. Argo (Ben Affleck) 7. War Horse (Steven Spielberg) 8. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 9. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 10. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (Peter Jackson) |
Top 10 Released *
1). Seven Psychopaths (McDonagh) 2). Toata Lumea Din Familia Noastra (Jude) 3). Holy Motors (Carax) 4). Killer Joe (Friedkin) 5). Skyfall (Mendes) 6). Despre Oameni Si Melci (Giurgiu) 7). Argo (Affleck) 8). Dredd (Travis) Top 10 Unreleased 1). Just The Wind (Fliegauf) 2). Amour (Haneke) 3). Living (Sigarev) 4). Compliance (Zobel) 5). Beasts of The Southern Wild (Zeitlin) 6). La Noche De Enfrente (Ruiz) 7). Quitting Smoking By Smoking (Pacinotti) 8). Moonrise Kingdom (Anderson) 9). Zero Dark Thirty (Bigelow) 10). Paradise: Love (Seidl) |
Topuri provizorii
Top 10 Released 1. We Need to Talk About Kevin (ce m-a zdruncinat filmul asta) 2. The Artist 3. The Dark Knight Rises 4. The Pirates! Band of Misfits 5. War Horse 6. The Avengers 7. Looper 8. Haywire 9. ParaNorman 10. The Ides of March Doar primul are o pozitie sigura in clasament, restul sunt mai greu de pus in ordine. Mare dezamagire personala in ceea ce priveste Prometheus, pe care l-am asteptat ca pe painea calda de cand am auzit ca urmeaza sa apara si din pacate mi s-a parut ca s-a incurcat prea mult in filozofia aia obosita ce cam domina filmul :( . Tare mi-ar fi placut sa il includ in top dar nu reusesc sa gasesc motive suficiente. Top Unreleased 1. Flight 2. Pieta 3. The Raid: Redemption 4. Amour 5. Rust and Bone 6. The Cabin in the Woods 7. Bernie |
Released:
1. We Need to Talk About Kevin (Lynne Ramsay) 2. Oslo, 31 august (Joachim Trier) 3. Holy Motors (Leos Carax) 4. Hodejegerne (Morten Tyldum) 5. Carnage (Roman Polanski) 6. Polisse (Maïwenn) 7. Killer Joe (William Friedkin) 8. En kongelig affære (Nikolaj Arcel) 9. Le Havre (Aki Kaurismaki) Unreleased: 1. Rust and Bone (Jacques Audiard) 2. Amour (Michael Haneke) 3. Killing Them Softly (Andrew Dominik) 4. Pieta (Ki-duk Kim) 5. Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson) 6. Cosmopolis (David Cronenberg) |
Released:
1. Dupa dealuri 2. Intouchables 3. Le gamin au vélo 4. Le Havre 5. The Artist 6. The Avengers 7. Carnage 8. Ted |
Update:
Top 10 Released: 1. Cloud Atlas (Tom Tykwer, Andy Wachowski, Lana Wachowski) 2. Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (Tomas Alfredson) 3. Life of Pi (Ang Lee) 4. The Artist (Michel Hazanavicius) 5. Lawless (John Hillcoat) 6. Argo (Ben Affleck) 7. War Horse (Steven Spielberg) 8. The Dark Knight Rises (Christopher Nolan) 9. Skyfall (Sam Mendes) 10. Brave (Mark Andrews, Brenda Chapman, Steve Purcell) |
Update:
Released: 1. Oslo, August 31st 2. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 3. Dupa Dealuri 4. We Need to Talk About Kevin 5. Holy Motors 6. Seven Psychopaths 7. A Royal Affair 8. Le Havre 9. Looper Unreleased: 1. Shame 2. Amour 3. In the fog 4. This is not a film 5. The deep blue sea 6. Like someone in love 7. Moonrise kingdom 8. Tabu 9. Killing them softly 10. The cabin in the woods Stiu ca unele au data initiala de lansare in 2011, dar a fost imposibil sa fie vazute la timp pt topul de anul trecut, asa ca prefer sa le trec pe ele, chiar daca nu sunt luate la socoteala, decat sa dau 1/2/3 puncte unor filme care nu neaparat merita... de altfel inca sper sa inlocuiesc ultimele doua locuri din 'unreleased'. Si in caz ca nu se iau la socoteala filmele respective sa se avanseze celelalte filme. |
Update:
Released: 1. Holy Motors 2. Oslo, August 31st 3. Dupa Dealuri 4. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 5. We Need to Talk About Kevin 6. Toata Lumea din Familia Noastra 7. Carnage Unreleased: 1. Shame 2. The Turin Horse 3. L'Apollonide 4. Cosmopolis 5. Once Upon a Time in Anatolia 6. Berberian Sound Studio 7. Into the Abyss 8. Moonrise Kingdom 9. Kill List |
Top Ten Unreleased
1. Tabu (Miguel Gomes) 2. Into the Abyss (Werner Herzog) 3. Autrement, la Molussie (Nicolas Rey) 4. Beasts of the Southern Wild (Benh Zeitlin) 5. Cosmopolis (David Cronenberg) 6. Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson) 7. Barbara (Christian Petzold) 8. In Another Country (Hong Sang-soo) 9. Laurence Anyways (Xavier Dolan) 10. Donoma (Djinn Carrénard) Deocamdata e provizoriu. Mai sunt cateva filme pe care vreau sa le vad, dar nu cred ca se va schimba mare lucru. |
Am modificat criteriul de eligibilitate pentru Unreleased:
"Filme care au avut premiera in 2012 (in cel putin o tara) dar nu s-au lansat in Romania." Acum libertatea e practic totala. Cu bune si cu rele. Unii vor pune filme pe care altii le-au votat anul trecut si chiar au aparut in Top10-ul final, etc. Dar daca se doreste libertate, asa sa fie. :) |
Eu o sa fac un top unic ca nu stiu ce s-a lansat si ce nu.
1. Amour 2. Dupa Dealuri 3. Holy Motors 4. Shame 5. Once Upon a Time in Anatolia 6. Beats of the Southern Wild 7. The Hunt 8. Seven Psychopaths 9. Moonrise Kingdom 10. Cosmopolis |
Daca ai fi citit OP-ul ai fi stiut.
|
Ce e ala OP? :)
|
Opening Post, cred:P Oricum, e un link acolo, la ala se refera.
|
Ah, mersi. L-am vazut. Nu prea am chef sa consult liste ca sa fac liste....dar daca-i absolut necesar o sa o impart in doua.
|
Nu ca-i obligatoriu. Dar ca sa-l pot lua in calcul pt clasamentele finale.
|
Dar daca un film are premiera in februarie in Romania( Amour sau Hitchcock), mai este eligibil pentru categoria Unreleased?
|
Da. Topurile de acum sunt pt anul 2012, iar ele au premiera in Romania in 2013. O sa poata intra si la released cand facem topurile pt 2013.
|
Originally Posted by Chambord:
1. Life of Pi 2. The cronicle of Narnia : Prince Caspian 3. The hobbits 4. Argo 5. Dupa dealuri. 6. Despre oameni si melci. 7. An expecting Journey. 8. Harry Potter: the goblet of fire. 9. Puss in bott. 10. Minte-ma frumos. |
Top 10 Released
1. We Need to Talk about Kevin 2. Oslo, August 31st 3. Dupa dealuri 4. Diaz: Don’t Clean Up That Blood 5. Le Havre 6. Toata lumea din familia noastra 7. Holy Motors 8. Le Gamin au velo 9. 7 Psychopaths 10. Hesher |
monicarusu25, incearca sa nu mai postezi atunci cand te afli sub influenta bauturilor alcoolice ! Cand te trezesti, vezi tu singurica ce nu-i in regula la topul tau. Si nu-i nevoie sa dai quote la OP.
|
Top 10 Released
Top 10 Released
1.Argo 2.Life of Pi 3.Cloud Atlas 4.The Artist 5.Skyfall 6.The Avengers 7.Ted 8.The Dark Knight Rises 9.Savages 10.Ice Age: Continental Drift |
Unreleased
1. Tabu (Miguel Gomes) 2. Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson) 3. Zero Dark Thirty (Kathryn Bigelow) 4. This Is Not a Film (Jafar Panahi & Mojtaba Mirtahmasb) 5. Amour (Michael Haneke) 6. Beasts of the Southern Wild (Benh Zeitlin) |
Realeased update
1. Dupa dealuri 2. We need to talk about Kevin 3. Cloud Atlas 4. End of watch 5. The Artist 6. Argo 7. A royal affair 8. Oslo, 31 august 9. La source des femmes 10. Hasta la vista Unrealeased 1. Shame 2. Pieta 3. Monsieur Lahzar 4. Amour 5. Lincoln 6. De rouille et d'os 7. Rundksop 8. Killing them softly 9. Kon-Tiki 10. Barbara (le-am subliniat pe cele din 2011 pt care se aplica noua regula) |
Update:
Released: 1. Dupa dealuri (Cristian Mungiu) 2. We Need to Talk About Kevin (Lynne Ramsay) 3. Oslo, 31 august (Joachim Trier) 4. Argo (Ben Affleck) 5. Holy Motors (Leos Carax) 6. Hodejegerne (Morten Tyldum) 7. Carnage (Roman Polanski) 8. Polisse (Maïwenn) 9. Killer Joe (William Friedkin) 10. En kongelig affære (Nikolaj Arcel) Unreleased: 1. The Turin Horse (Bela Tarr) 2. Django Unchained (Quentin Tarantino) 3. Rust and Bone (Jacques Audiard) 4. Shame (Steve McQueen) 5. Amour (Michael Haneke) 6. Rundskop (Michael R. Roskam) 7. Killing Them Softly (Andrew Dominik) 8. Pieta (Ki-duk Kim) 9. Moonrise Kingdom (Wes Anderson) 10. Cosmopolis (David Cronenberg) |
UPDATE
Top 10 Released 1). Seven Psychopaths (McDonagh) 2). Toata Lumea Din Familia Noastra (Jude) 3). Holy Motors (Carax) 4). Killer Joe (Friedkin) 5). Skyfall (Mendes) 6). Despre Oameni Si Melci (Giurgiu) 7). Argo (Affleck) 8). Dredd (Travis) Top 10 Unreleased 1). Just The Wind (Fliegauf) 2). Amour (Haneke) 3). Living (Sigarev) 4). The Master (Anderson) 5). Compliance (Zobel) 6). Beasts of The Southern Wild (Zeitlin) 7). La Noche De Enfrente (Ruiz) 8). Quitting Smoking By Smoking (Pacinotti) 9). Moonrise Kingdom (Anderson) 10). Zero Dark Thirty (Bigelow) |
| All times are GMT +2. The time now is 12:32. |
Powered by vBulletin - Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.